âAll citizens born or naturalized in the United States, and
subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and the state wherein they reside.â The clear purpose of the Fourteenth Amendment, ratified in 1868, three years after the end of the Civil War, was to guarantee full citizenship rights to now emancipated former slaves. It was not intended to guarantee untrammeled immigration to the United States.
Some 4 million anchor babies are now officially U.S. citizens. This has to stop. The only other major country in the world that issues citizenship based on where oneâs mother delivers her child is Canada. The rest of the world bases citizenship on who the kidâs parents are, which is of course the only sane standard. 14 If a pregnant American mother is traveling to Egypt on business and goes into delivery, do we instantly declare her child an Egyptian? Of course not. But thatâs precisely what goes on every day in America: women who have zero connection to the United States cross the border, deliver a baby, and their kid magically becomes an American citizen eligible to receive all the rights and benefits of those who have lived, worked, and paid taxes in our country.
Republican Senators John Kyl of Arizona and Lindsey Graham of South Carolina have discussed introducing a constitutional amendment to clarify and restore the original intent of the Fourteenth Amendment. Itâs long past time that America joins the rest of the world in granting citizenship along rational lines.
Liberal Myths
But in restoring sanity to the interpretation and enforcement of our laws, weâll have to fight liberal myths every step of the way. Weâve all heard a million times: âWe need illegal immigrants because they are willing to
do jobs Americans just wonât.â To that one I say, âSays who?â We have 25 million citizens who need jobs, and 7 million illegal immigrants holding American jobs. Do the math. If illegal aliens werenât holding these jobs, American citizens would, because these jobs need to be filled, and guess what? Those jobs would pay more than they do now, because illegal low-wage workers drive down wage rates. Even the Washington Post has conceded that âan influx of immigrants has helped depress the incomes of low-skilled workers in recent decades, many economists agree.â 15 As research by Harvard University economist George J. Borjas has shown, âthe primary losers in this country are workers who do not have high school diplomas, particularly blacks and native-born Hispanics.â Borjas found that from 1980 to 2000, illegal immigrants lowered the nationâs average wages some 7.4 percent for Americaâs 10 million native-born men who lack a high school diploma. 16 You would think that Obama, who talks a good game about caring for the poor, would try to help raise wages for people at the bottom of the economic ladder. But with black teenage unemployment now at a staggering 46.5 percent, and with the overall black underemployment rate at a breathtaking 18.8 percent, itâs outrageous that the president continues to mock Republican efforts to reduce illegal immigration and boost wages. 17
âAll the stuff they [Republicans] ask for, weâve done,â said Obama at a 2011 immigration rally in El Paso, Texas. âMaybe theyâll need a moat,â Obama said to laughter. âMaybe they want alligators in the moat! Theyâll never be satisfied.â 18
Mr. President, you might think the border deaths, narco terrorists, and waves of violent illegal criminals into America are a joke, but the people who live along the border and the communities under siege do not. We need a president who will get tough, enforce our laws, protect our people, and pull wages up.
One of the biggest myths we have been told is that illegal immigrants actually produce a net gain economically. This is a cute argument, but itâs a
Greg Herren
Crystal Cierlak
T. J. Brearton
Thomas A. Timmes
Jackie Ivie
Fran Lee
Alain de Botton
William R. Forstchen
Craig McDonald
Kristina M. Rovison