âbut donât ever ask for a day off, okay?â
âHuh?â Pipp said. âWhy not?â
âYouâre not gonna believe this,â I explained, âbut in a few years, youâre gonna have a headache. And youâre gonna ask for a day off. And some young guy named Lou Gehrig is gonna take your place that day. And heâs gonna be so good that heâs gonna take your job. And the Yankees are gonna sell you to Cincinnati. Trust me on this.â
Wally Pipp looked at me like I was crazy.
âHow would you know whatâs gonna happen in a few years?â he asked. âI never even heard of nobody named Gehrig. You really are sick, kid. Maybe you better get back to the hospital.â
I could have tried to convince Wally Pipp not to ask for a day off. I could have argued with him. But there was no point. My mom always told me that youâve got to choose your battles in life. I had more important things to do than save Wally Pippâs career.
âForget it,â I told Pipp. âThanks for the ball. Can you tell me where I might find Carl Mays?â
Pipp pointed to a locker all the way in the corner of the clubhouse.
âOver there,â Pipp told me. âBut donât bother him. He donât like beinâ bothered. Especially today. Heâs going for his 100th career victory.â
Carl Mays was sitting on a bench by himself, hunched over with his back to me. He was strippedto the waist, wearing gym shorts. He looked lost in thought. His foot was nervously tapping the floor.
As I got closer, I could see there was a scar on the back of his left leg, maybe six inches long. On the floor of his locker were four pairs of baseball shoes, all shined up and lined up perfectly in a row. There were a few bats leaning against the wall behind me, also perfectly in a line. He must have been a neat freak.
Suddenly, I had an incredible idea. I could accomplish my mission right here and now. I didnât have to give a batting helmet to Ray Chapman to save his life. All I had to do was pick up one of those bats and whack Carl Mays on his pitching arm with it!
If he was injured, he wouldnât be able to play. And if he wasnât able to play, he wouldnât be able to hit Ray Chapman in the head with a ball. And if he didnât hit Chapman with the ballâ¦well, you get the idea.
It would be so easy !
My mind was racing, but I had to think this thing through. If I whacked Mays with the bat, the rest of the Yankees would surely surround me in about two seconds and beat the crap out of me. Iâd most likely get arrested and possibly thrown in jail. If they took away my new pack of baseball cards, there would be no way for me to get back home again. Iâd be stuck in 1920 forever.
It was a dilemma. If I whacked Mays with the bat, I would be saving Ray Chapmanâs life and possibly ruining my own. Is it the right thing to do to hurt somebody if it would save somebody elseâs life? I didnât know.
I eyed the bats. I could always argue that by hitting Mays with a bat, I was saving two lives. Chapman wouldnât die, and Mays wouldnât have to go through the rest of his life knowing that he killed Chapman.
But who would believe me afterward when I explained that I was only trying to help these guys? I was the only person in 1920 who knew that Ray Chapman was going to be dead in a matter of hours. Nobody else had a clue. They would just think I was some crazy kid who attacked Carl Mays with a bat.
There wasnât a lot of time to work out all the consequences. I had to make a decision fast.
I put down the ball that Wally Pipp gave me. I picked up one of Carl Maysâs bats.
10
All Part of the Game
I N THE END , I DIDNâT HAVE TO DECIDE WHETHER OR NOT to attack Carl Mays with his own baseball bat. Because at that moment, he turned around and looked at me.
I could have swung the bat, anyway. Mays would have been so surprised, he
Madison Daniel
Charlene Weir
Lynsay Sands
BWWM Club, Tyra Small
Matt Christopher
Sophie Stern
Karen Harbaugh
Ann Cleeves
John C. Wohlstetter
Laura Lippman