Harveyâs dead. Charlie, I know you know him. I saw you talking to him before they argued.â
âI talked to a lot of people last night. Ever hear of mingling?â
âThat wasnât mingling. You know him. Who is he?â
Charlie stared out the window for a long time. âI canât talk about him. Not yet.â
âYou better talk about him soon. I have to tell Clark what I saw. He could have something to do with the murder.â
âHe didnât.â
âThen tell me who he is. Tell me why he was arguing with Harvey.â She was silent. âCharlie, this doesnât look good.â
âDid you hear what they were arguing about?â she asked.
âNo.â
âDid he see you?â she asked.
âHe had to. He looked right at me when I tried to stop him.â
She tapped a pen on the mouse pad and then threw it at the wall. It bounced off and landed on the desk, and then rolled to the edge and fell to the floor. Charlie punched her fist into the mouse pad and the whole desk shook.
âCharlie, whatâs going on? Who is that guy?â
âThat guy is the closest thing I have to family.â
Before I could react, Charlie held up her hand to stop me. âRemember how I told you once that I bounced around different foster homes after I was given up for adoption?â
I nodded.
âThe older I got, the less anybody wanted me. Eventually I took off with everything I owned, which wasnât much, and hitchhiked until I ended up in Encino. I moved in with a mechanic because he said he had a room for rent. His name was Ned Rains.â She tipped her head toward the street, and even though the man with the ponytail wasnât there, I knew who she meant. âHe wasnât much older than I wasâtwenty-two to my fourteen. It was his auto shop. I didnât have any money, so I took care of the food and laundry and stuff, but that got real boring real fast. I started hanging around while he worked on cars, helping him when I could. He taught me about engines and oil changes and transmission flushes.â
âWere you and heâ I mean, did heâ I meanââ
âNo. He understood that Iâd had a hard life up to that point, and he took me in. He even helped me try to find the people who gave me up for adoption. When it was time for me to leave, he gave me two thousand dollars and said I should forget the past and start a life of my own. I moved here, got a job at the auto shop, and saved up until the owner was ready to sell to me. This has been my shop ever since.â
âBut you and Ned kept in touch.â
âYes. When you first came to town and found out my secret, I needed to get away. I showed up on his doorstep without much more than I did the first time.â
âDoes Clark know any of this?â
âWhat does Clark have to do with it?â
âYouâre having a relationship with him, or I think you are. Thereâs this thing people do when theyâre in a relationship. They talk about what made them the person they are. Itâs sometimes referred to as âgetting to know each other,ââ I said, using finger quotes.
âClark knows Iâm a private person, and he knows if he so much as glances at a background check of me, Iâll kick him to the curb.â
âClarkâs not dumb. Heâs going to look into anybody connected to Harvey Halliwell, and it wonât take long for him to start asking questions. Why is Ned here? Why now?â
âI told you, I canât talk about that.â She looked up at me. âYouâre not going to turn this into your latest rescue mission, are you?â
âIâm just trying to find out the truth. Somebody killed Harvey Halliwell.â
âNed didnât do it. Their argument was about something else. Let me talk to him first before you go to Clark.â
âI donât feel good about this,â I