like Avery. Gretchen must have gotten her frizzy dark hair from her father. Dad told me Gretchenâs father died when Gretchen was very young. Stick kept his name and never remarried.
(If anyone around here should feel sad, and heavy, and unable to get up and brush her teeth before bed, it should be Gretchen, or Stick.)
(Not me.)
(So get it together, Finley.)
âHere, Finley.â Grandma hands me an old cloth. âStart wiping down those bottom cabinets, please. Iâd like to get this done quickly so I can be at the clinic by one oâclock.â
âClinic?â
Grandma waves a hand. âJust something I do when I have the time.â
âYour grandmaâs being modest.â Stick loops her arm through Grandmaâs. âShe volunteers at the clinic, works the front desk. Whenever they need her, she drops everything and goes. And she organizes this back-to-school program at the Y, where they stuff backpacks full of school supplies for kids who need them. You know, so their parents donât have to worry about spending money on notebooks and pens and such. Your grandma, Fin.â Stick beams at me. âSheâs the best, in case you didnât know.â
Stick plants a sweaty kiss on Grandmaâs cheek, and Grandmaâs nose wrinkles. I try not to laugh.
âIt keeps me from getting bored around here in this old house, is all,â Grandma says crisply. âNow get to cleaning, you two.â
Stick flips on the radio. âGretchen has been talking about you nonstop all week, Finley,â she tells me while she sweeps. She stops to gulp down some of her shake. âShe couldnât wait to come backâand for once it had nothing to do with Grandmaâs cooking.â
I wait for Grandma to laugh, but sheâs elbow deep in asoapy sink, scrubbing hard at a pan that looks perfectly clean to me.
âIâm just so excited you two have hit it off,â Stick continues. âItâs been a long time since Iâve seen Gretchen so excited about playing outside. Trees? And mud? Come on. Usually itâs nothing but video games and texting her friends. I should never have gotten her a phone so young. But all her friends had them, so if I didnât get her one, sheâd be constantly whining about it. Here.â Stick holds out her shake. âWanna try?â
Stick looks so hopeful that I take a sip. It tastes like a combination of gritty cake and liquid metal. I fight not to make a face.
Stick bursts out laughing. âNot for you, huh, babycakes?â She kisses my forehead and ruffles my hair. âDonât worry, I still like you.â
I smile up at Stick. Her short hair pokes up behind her headband. âYou do?â
âOf course! Youâre my coolest niece by far.â
âEven cooler than Avery?â
Stick winks at me. âDonât tell her I said that.â
âYou were playing outside?â Grandma has stopped scrubbing to look at me.
It takes me a minute to remember what we were talking aboutâthe Everwood. Playing outside with Gretchen.
I wait for Stick to say something, but suddenly she seems to be very interested in sweeping.
âUm. Yeah?â
âYes,â Grandma says.
âI mean . . . yes. Itâs no big deal. We were just messing around.â
âDoing what, exactly? And where?â
Stick stops sweeping. âMom, come on. Theyâre just having fun.â
âAmelia, I asked Finley, not you.â
âWe talked. Hung out in the pit.â My mind ping-pongs around, searching for a reason why Grandma would be acting this way. Playing outside seems like a normal thing to do, but I get the sense that isnât true at Hart House.
Then it hits me:
Maybe Grandma knows about what Gretchen and I found: the childâs shoe, the twisted bicycle. The knife.
Maybe she knows about something that happened in the Everwood.
âI donât want you girls playing
Faisal Islam
Ian Hamilton
Howard Schultz
Ruby Shae
Alicia Roberts
Enrique Flores-Galbis
Susan Wittig Albert
J. Kathleen Cheney
Thomas Mullen
My False Heart